I have to saw, the collie is absolutely adorable ^u^ Its so very realistic :3 I absolutely adore the clouds. There so life-like. It makes it FEEL as if you are in the sky <3 The one thing I would add is add more white to the clouds. But overall on the clouds you did and AMAZING JOB! I still love them<3 Again, so LIFE-LIKE! x)
The collie's fur is so realistic! The PERFECT color! It makes me want to pet the collie xD The fur seems very soft and you an amazing job with the shading! :] I love how you made white tips on the fur and a little white all around the collie :3 Just to add lighting There are no words for how amazing the eyes are<3 VERY VERY VERY realistic ;] The ears, nose, and face fur are EXQUISITE! Very life-like, smooth, realistic, and a job well done on shading! The only thing that I would change is the size of the tongue. When it hangs it realistic but the back of the tongue is very...large and uneven from the front where it hangs. I would just make it skinnier. The teeth are perfect tho<3 Just the tongue.
Overall, you did a WONDERFUL job!<3 The whole picture is very realistic The only things I would change is make the back of the tongue skinnier and add more white to the clouds :] Still, you did an AMAZING job! <3 Absolutely love it<3 ;D
(MY FIRST CRITIQUE YAY!?) You did a very good job on this. I outta say you did a great job in the collie, even the color choice as well. But the only flaw is the clouds. I'm not saying the clouds are bad, I'm just saying you should whiten it a little more. Other than that your artwork is magnificant!
I really love this artwork it's gorgeous. Even if you messed up a little bit it's just gorgeous! But there's a little flaw on the collie, there's a little squiggle on it. Other than those two flaws it's fine. Great job!